AQA GCSE · Question 11.2 · Cognition and Behaviour
Outline how psychologists would explain the Müller-Lyer illusion.
How to approach this question
1. Name the key theory: Gregory's constructivist theory or 'misapplied size constancy'.
2. Explain the role of depth cues: Describe how the fins are interpreted as representing corners of buildings/rooms.
3. Link to size constancy: Explain that because one line is perceived as further away, our brain compensates for the distance and perceives it as larger.
Full Answer
Richard Gregory's constructivist theory of perception provides the most common explanation for the Müller-Lyer illusion. He argued that perception is an active process of 'hypothesis testing' based on past knowledge and experience. In a world filled with buildings (a 'carpentered world'), we learn to interpret angles as depth cues. The fins-in figure looks like the far corner of a room, while the fins-out figure looks like the near corner of a building. Our brain uses this depth information and applies size constancy scaling. If two objects cast the same size image on our retina, but one is perceived as being further away, our brain concludes the further object must be larger. This is 'misapplied' constancy because the depth cues are on a 2D surface, leading to the illusion.
Common mistakes
Simply stating it's an illusion without explaining the psychological mechanism. Forgetting to mention 'size constancy' or 'depth cues'.