Medium4 marksStructured
AQA GCSE · Question 03.2 · Atomic structure and the periodic table
Compare model A with the model of the atom used today.
Use Figure 2.
Compare model A with the model of the atom used today.
Use Figure 2.
How to approach this question
Think about the key features of Model A (the plum pudding model) and the modern atomic model (the Bohr model/quantum mechanical model).
1. **Similarities:** What subatomic particles or properties do they have in common?
2. **Differences:** How is the positive charge arranged differently? Where are the electrons located in each model? What subatomic particle is missing from Model A? What does the modern model say about the volume of the atom?
Full Answer
A comparison should include both similarities and differences between the Plum Pudding model (Model A) and the modern atomic model.
**Similarities:**
* Both models contain positively charged components and negatively charged electrons.
* Both models represent an atom that is electrically neutral overall, with the amount of positive and negative charge balancing out.
**Differences:**
* **Arrangement of Positive Charge:** In Model A, the positive charge is spread out as a diffuse sphere. In the modern model, the positive charge is concentrated in a tiny, dense nucleus at the center of the atom.
* **Location of Electrons:** In Model A, electrons are randomly embedded within the positive sphere. In the modern model, electrons orbit the nucleus in specific energy levels or shells.
* **Subatomic Particles:** The modern model includes neutrons (neutral particles) within the nucleus, which were not discovered at the time of Model A and are therefore absent.
* **Structure:** Model A depicts the atom as a solid sphere. The modern model shows the atom as being mostly empty space, with the mass concentrated in the nucleus.
Common mistakes
✗ Only giving differences and no similarities, or vice versa.
✗ Vague statements like "they are different" without explaining how.
✗ Confusing the features of the different models.
Practice the full AQA GCSE Chemistry Higher Tier Paper 1
44 questions · hints · full answers · grading
More questions from this exam
Q01.1A student produced a salt by reacting copper carbonate with sulfuric acid.
This is the method use...EasyQ01.2Give one observation the student could make during Step 4 which shows that the copper carbonate i...EasyQ01.3Give one reason for filtering the mixture in Step 5.EasyQ01.4Name the equipment that can be used to warm the filtrate gently in Step 6.EasyQ01.5The maximum theoretical mass of the salt that could be produced using 50 cm³ of the sulfuric acid...Medium
Expert