For IndividualsFor Educators
ExpertMinds LogoExpertMinds
ExpertMinds

Ace your certifications with Practice Exams and AI assistance.

  • Browse Exams
  • For Educators
  • Blog
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Cookie Policy
  • Support
  • AWS SAA Exam Prep
  • PMI PMP Exam Prep
  • CPA Exam Prep
  • GCP PCA Exam Prep

© 2026 TinyHive Labs. Company number 16262776.

    PracticeACCAACCA LW — Corporate and Business Law Practice Exam 6Question 57
    Medium2 marksMultiple Choice
    Management, administration and the regulation of companiesManagement, administration and the regulation of companiesMinority protection
    This question is part of a case study — click to read the full scenario(Case 55)

    Section B - Scenario 4

    HarvestYield plc is a large agricultural company. The board of directors decides to close a profitable local farm to consolidate operations in a mega-farm 100 miles away. This decision will devastate the local rural economy and cause 50 redundancies. The directors made the decision solely to increase the annual dividend for shareholders.

    Under s.172 of the Companies Act 2006, have the directors breached their duty to promote the success of the company?

    View full case study page →

    ACCA · Question 57 · Management, administration and the regulation of companies

    Section B - Scenario 4

    HarvestYield plc is a large agricultural company. The directors of HarvestYield plc negligently purchase contaminated fertilizer, causing £500,000 in damages to the company's crops. The directors refuse to allow the company to sue the supplier because the supplier is a company owned by the CEO's brother. A minority shareholder wishes to take legal action.

    What type of claim should the minority shareholder bring?

    Answer options:

    A.

    An unfair prejudice petition under s.994.

    B.

    A derivative claim on behalf of the company against the directors for breach of duty.

    C.

    A personal action against the supplier in the tort of negligence.

    D.

    A petition for the just and equitable winding up of the company.

    How to approach this question

    Distinguish between the remedies available to minority shareholders. Who suffered the loss? The company. Therefore, the claim must be on behalf of the company.

    Full Answer

    B.A derivative claim on behalf of the company against the directors for breach of duty.✓ Correct
    Under Part 11 of the Companies Act 2006, a derivative claim allows a shareholder to bring a claim on behalf of the company against a director for negligence, default, breach of duty, or breach of trust. This is the appropriate mechanism when the wrongdoers control the company and refuse to let the company sue.

    Common mistakes

    Confusing a derivative claim (company's loss) with an unfair prejudice petition (shareholder's personal loss).
    Question 56All questionsQuestion 58

    Practice the full ACCA LW — Corporate and Business Law Practice Exam 6

    60 questions · hints · full answers · grading

    Sign up freeTake the exam

    More questions from this exam

    Q01Section A In the context of the English legal system, which of the following statements accurate...MediumQ02Section A Which of the following courts binds the High Court but is NOT bound by its own previou...MediumQ03Section A In the context of the law of contract, which TWO of the following statements regarding...MediumQ04Section A Zephyr Ltd, a wind turbine manufacturer, promises to pay a £5,000 bonus to an independ...HardQ05Section A In the tort of negligence, which of the following best describes the 'Caparo test' for...Medium
    View all 60 questions →