ExpertHard12 marksExtended Response
AQA GCSE · Question 10 · Crime and Deviance
Discuss how far sociologists would agree that prison is an effective form of social control.
Discuss how far sociologists would agree that prison is an effective form of social control.
How to approach this question
Structure your answer as a debate.
1. Introduction: Briefly state that there are different sociological views on the effectiveness of prison.
2. Argument FOR effectiveness: Explain the functionalist view (deterrence, retribution, reinforcing norms).
3. Argument AGAINST effectiveness: Explain the Marxist view (tool of class control, ignores corporate crime) and the interactionist view (labelling, 'universities of crime', high recidivism).
4. Use evidence/concepts: Refer to recidivism rates, alternative punishments (community service), and key concepts like 'social solidarity' and 'self-fulfilling prophecy'.
5. Conclusion: Summarise the arguments and offer a justified judgement on 'how far' you agree (e.g., it is largely ineffective at rehabilitation but effective at incapacitation).
Full Answer
This question requires an evaluation of the role of prison in society from different sociological perspectives. Functionalists (like Durkheim) see punishment as functional for society, reinforcing the collective conscience and maintaining social order. Marxists see the law and its enforcement as part of the ideological state apparatus, serving the interests of the ruling class by criminalising the poor. Interactionists focus on the micro-level effects of prison, such as the negative label of 'ex-convict' and the way prisons can become 'schools for crime'. A good answer will contrast these views and use evidence like high reoffending rates to support the argument that prison is often ineffective at its stated goal of rehabilitation.
Common mistakes
Only presenting one side of the argument (e.g., only criticising prisons) without acknowledging the functionalist perspective. Not using specific sociological theories or concepts. Providing a list of points rather than a structured essay.
Practice the full AQA GCSE Sociology Paper 2
22 questions · hints · full answers · grading
More questions from this exam
Q01What term is commonly used by sociologists to describe the amount of crime that goes unreported t...EasyQ02What term is commonly used by sociologists to describe the system of law enforcement in the Unite...EasyQ03Describe one way in which deviance can be seen to be socially constructed.MediumQ04Identify and describe one example of corporate crime.MediumQ05SOURCE TEXT:
Item A
There are concerns from some social commentators about the relatively high l...Medium