Hard9 marksExtended Response
AQA GCSE · Question 02.3 · Business in the real world
Jameel would have three months to make the 100 toys for the local toy shop.\n\nRecommend whether Jameel should create a business plan before making a decision about accepting the order. Give reasons for your recommendation.
Jameel would have three months to make the 100 toys for the local toy shop.\n\nRecommend whether Jameel should create a business plan before making a decision about accepting the order. Give reasons for your recommendation.
How to approach this question
1. **Start with a clear recommendation:** "Jameel should..." or "Jameel should not...".
2. **Develop your first point:** Explain a reason FOR creating a business plan. Use evidence from Item A (e.g., "time consuming to make", "uncertain whether to create a business plan"). Explain the impact of this on Jameel.
3. **Develop your second point:** Explain another reason FOR creating a business plan (e.g., to set objectives, to secure finance). Link it to the case study.
4. **Develop a counter-argument:** Explain a reason AGAINST creating a business plan (e.g., it takes time, he needs to start "immediately").
5. **Conclude:** Weigh up the points you have made and justify your final recommendation. Which side of the argument is stronger and why?
Full Answer
A business plan is a formal document outlining a business's goals, and the strategies for achieving them. \n\n**Arguments for creating a plan:**\n* **Reduces Risk:** It forces Jameel to analyse costs, forecast sales, and assess the profitability of the order. This helps him avoid taking on a loss-making project.\n* **Secures Finance:** If he needs a loan for materials, a bank will require a business plan.\n* **Provides Direction:** It sets clear objectives and a plan of action, helping him to manage his time and resources effectively over the three months.\n* **Identifies Problems:** The process might highlight potential issues, such as not having enough time or the right tools.\n\n**Arguments against creating a plan:**\n* **Time-Consuming:** Jameel needs to start production "immediately". Writing a plan takes time he may not have.\n* **Inflexibility:** A rigid plan might be unhelpful for a new, small-scale venture where things can change quickly.\n* **Uncertainty:** The toy shop will only pay for what sells, making revenue forecasts difficult and potentially inaccurate.\n\nA good answer will weigh these points, use the context from Item A, and make a justified final judgement.
Common mistakes
✗ Not making a clear recommendation (e.g., "he could do it or he could not").\n✗ Just listing points about business plans without applying them to Jameel's specific situation (e.g., the time pressure, the trial order).\n✗ Not providing a balanced argument that considers the other side.
Practice the full AQA GCSE Business Paper 1
26 questions · hints · full answers · grading
More questions from this exam
Q01.1Which of the following characteristics of an entrepreneur is the ability to develop new ideas/pro...EasyQ01.2Which of the following describes the chain of command?EasyQ01.3Which of the following is a definition of a part time contract of employment?EasyQ01.4Which of the following is the formula for total costs?EasyQ01.5Which of the following is the next stage in the selection process after the closing date for job ...Easy
Expert