Medium2 marksStructured
AQA GCSE · Question 05.7 · Infection and Response
Different types of disease may interact. Scientists studied the incidence of malaria infections in children:
• with disorder S
• without disorder S.
The incidence of malaria in children with disorder S was calculated as a percentage of the incidence in children without disorder S. Table 4 shows the results. Describe what the results in Table 4 show about the interaction between disorder S and malaria.
Different types of disease may interact. Scientists studied the incidence of malaria infections in children:
• with disorder S
• without disorder S.
The incidence of malaria in children with disorder S was calculated as a percentage of the incidence in children without disorder S. Table 4 shows the results. Describe what the results in Table 4 show about the interaction between disorder S and malaria.
How to approach this question
The percentage is for children *with* disorder S compared to children *without* it. If the percentage is 100%, there is no difference. If it's less than 100%, what does that mean for children with disorder S? If it's more than 100%, what does that mean?
Describe the overall trend and also look for any changes in the trend as age increases. Use data from the table to support your description.
Full Answer
The results show an interaction where disorder S appears to offer some protection against malaria.
1. **General Protection:** All the percentage values are below 100%. This means that in every age group studied, children with disorder S had a lower incidence of malaria compared to children without the disorder. This suggests having disorder S is advantageous in areas where malaria is common.
2. **Age-related Trend:** The protective effect is strongest in the 8 to 10 age group, where the incidence of malaria is only 45% of that in children without disorder S. The protection seems to decrease from age 2 up to age 10, but then the incidence rises again for children over 10 (to 73%), suggesting the protective effect may weaken in older children.
(This pattern is characteristic of Sickle Cell Anaemia, where being a carrier (heterozygous) provides resistance to malaria).
Common mistakes
✗ Just quoting numbers without explaining what they mean in terms of interaction or protection.
✗ Getting the relationship the wrong way round, e.g., saying disorder S increases the risk of malaria.
✗ Failing to notice the change in the trend for the >10 age group.
Practice the full AQA GCSE Biology Higher Tier Paper 1
52 questions · hints · full answers · grading
More questions from this exam
Q01.1A root is a plant organ. Plant roots contain many different types of tissue. What is a tissue?EasyQ01.2Tissue in the tip of a plant root contains stem cells. Stem cells can differentiate into any type...EasyQ01.3In the past many drugs were extracted from plants. Aspirin is a painkiller. Which plant does aspi...EasyQ01.4Scientists have extracted chemical A from the deadly nightshade plant. Chemical A can be used as ...MediumQ01.5A deadly nightshade plant has chlorosis (yellow leaves). The mass of chemical A found in the leav...Medium
Expert