Question 1

SECTION A: STRATEGIC CASE STUDY

You are a tax manager in a firm of Chartered Certified Accountants. You have been asked to advise Arthur Pendelton, the founder and 100% shareholder of Forge Dynamics Ltd (FDL), a UK-resident heavy manufacturing company.

EXHIBIT 1: BACKGROUND OF FORGE DYNAMICS LTD (FDL)
FDL was incorporated in 2005. It operates two distinct divisions: 'Steel Forging' (manufacturing industrial components) and 'Advanced Robotics' (developing automated assembly line robots). Both divisions have traded profitably for over 10 years. FDL's current market value is estimated at £40 million, split equally between the two divisions. The base cost of Arthur's shares in FDL is £500,000.

EXHIBIT 2: PROPOSED RESTRUCTURING
Arthur, aged 62, wishes to step back from the business. He intends to gift the Steel Forging division to his daughter, Clara, who currently works in the business. However, Clara has no interest in the Advanced Robotics division. Arthur has received an offer from a third-party multinational, OmniTech PLC, to acquire the Advanced Robotics division for £20 million. 
Arthur is considering two options to achieve this:
Option 1: FDL sells the trade and assets of the Advanced Robotics division directly to OmniTech PLC, followed by a liquidation of FDL to distribute the proceeds to Arthur, who will then gift the remaining Steel Forging assets to Clara.
Option 2: A statutory demerger to separate the two divisions into two new holding companies, followed by Arthur selling his shares in the new Advanced Robotics holding company to OmniTech PLC, and gifting his shares in the new Steel Forging holding company to Clara.

EXHIBIT 3: ARTHUR'S PERSONAL TAX POSITION
Arthur is an additional rate taxpayer. He has fully utilized his annual exempt amount for Capital Gains Tax (CGT) and his nil rate band for Inheritance Tax (IHT). He has never previously claimed Business Asset Disposal Relief (BADR).

REQUIREMENTS:
Write a report to Arthur Pendelton advising him on the tax implications of his proposals. Your report should:
(a) Evaluate the Corporation Tax, Chargeable Gains, and Stamp Duty Land Tax (SDLT) implications for FDL under Option 1 versus Option 2. (18 marks)
(b) Calculate and advise on Arthur's personal Capital Gains Tax (CGT) position under both options, specifically addressing the availability of Business Asset Disposal Relief (BADR) and any clearance procedures required from HMRC. (15 marks)
(c) Discuss the Inheritance Tax (IHT) implications of gifting the Steel Forging business to Clara under both options, focusing on the availability of Business Relief (BR) and any potential pitfalls. (12 marks)
(d) Professional Skills: Demonstrate appropriate commercial acumen, clear communication, and professional skepticism throughout your report. (5 marks)

Accepted Answer

Approach this by structuring your answer exactly as requested: a professional report. Use headings for each sub-requirement. For part (a), contrast the double-tax charge of an asset sale + liquidation against the reliefs available in a statutory demerger. For part (b), explicitly state the BADR conditions (5% holding, officer/employee, 2 years) and apply them to the scenario. Mention HMRC clearances (s.138, s.701) as this is an advanced paper. For part (c), focus on the 'tacking' rules for Business Relief holding periods during a reconstruction.

Question 2

What mistakes do candidates make on this ACCA question?

Accepted Answer

Students often forget to discuss Stamp Duty and SDLT in corporate reorganizations. Another common error is failing to mention that the 2-year holding period for BADR and IHT Business Relief can 'carry over' (tack) from the original holding company to the newly demerged companies.

How to approach this question

Full Answer

Common mistakes

Practice the full ACCA ATX — Advanced Taxation Practice Exam 1

More questions from this exam